Transaction succeeds but internal payment may fail: Ethereum Glamsterdam upgrade testing uncovers compatibility issues
Odaily: Testing of Ethereum's proposed Glamsterdam upgrade has uncovered potential smart contract compatibility issues. On the Sepolia testnet, simulated tests of the Juicebox V6 payment contract showed that some transactions execute successfully overall, but internal payment operations may fail, causing fund distribution or fee payments to be skipped; in cash redemption tests, within the reported Gas range of 679,622 to 817,622, users could complete redemptions, but the 2.5% fee that should be paid was not executed. Developer mejango stated that this is related to the Gas consumption of different operations and error handling mechanisms: internal payments may fail due to insufficient Gas, and after the contract's try/catch captures the error, the outer operation still continues to execute.
Similar simulations conducted on the mainnet environment showed that within the sampled Gas ranges, only overall transaction failures or fully executed payments occurred, with no cases observed of internal payments being skipped. The Ethereum Foundation's November 16 testing meeting agenda has included the compatibility issue raised by Juicebox and related proof-of-concept for investigation and discussion under EIP-8037 and EIP-8038; the Foundation previously scheduled further discussion on November 19 regarding testing findings and follow-up measures, with no final decision pre-determined.
